I have been to the U.S. a few times. And a thing I learnt is that when you return to Germany you find most people really rude. After a few days/weeks you accomodate and you stop to notice and all is fine again. Staying at this B&B was like returning to Germany earlier than intended. It is run by Germans and the difference between the service you normally get in the U.S. and this place was striking.
We had booked several months in advance. We had also payed several months in advance, a point I did not at all feel comfortable with. It's one thing if a large site like hotels.com charges your credit card in advance for some unknown hotel on a different continent. You have your credit card company and hotels.com as safety net. It's a whole different story to transfer the full amount to some private checking account two months in advance. Additionally, at their request we paid in Euros (the currency of the hour) and we did not get an appropriate rate. I work in banking, I do know the rates.
Well, we had also stated an expected time of arrival two months in advance (4-6 p.m.). On the way to NYC we got into a traffic jam and we undererstimated the time required to travel from LaGuardia to the B&B. However, I didn't care because a) we still arrived arround 8.15 p.m. and more importantly b) we had already paid. On arrival we were asked why we were arriving so late. We told them about the traffic jam and thought to be done with it. Instead, we were critised that we had given a different hour.
Our room was nice, but the door a surprise. The door had a spring that shuts the door if you leave it open with a loud bang. We were told to always close the door, otherwise the door would bang. Going to the restroom I directly forgot and the door banged. Literally, 5s later one of our hosts told me that I had to close the door and that doing otherwise was really annoying. Just a hint: If the spring annoys you so much, just have it removed.
We didn't get of to a good start I would say. A few other issues: The breakfast was very simple (not at all German level, even worse than your average American breakfast). The bathroom holds a long list of how (not) tos. And in general, we were unsure if they really felt comfortable having guests. For certain, they were not interested in getting to know their guests.
Well, I still would give this place a 3 of 5. It is a nice building. The rooms are nice and clean and the bathrooms, too. The location is very good (up and coming quarter in Brooklyn) and you get easily to Manhattan. And the price was okay. Also, I am not an experienced NYC traveller, but I heard that service levels in New York are lower than in the rest of the U.S. We didn't stay long in our room, so on a rational level this is a good place to stay.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Would I recommend this hotel to my best friend?
probably not
I recommend this hotel for:
A romantic getaway, Girlfriend getaway, Older travelers, Pet owners, Families with young children, Families with teenagers, Tourists
I do not recommend this hotel for:
Young singles, An amazing honeymoon, A romantic getaway, People with disabilities, Older travelers, Great pool scene
I selected this hotel as a top choice for:
Museums / Cultural / Historical sites