On a positive note, check-in and check-out were fast and easy. The furnishings in the room were very nice, and the beds were extremely comfortable. There was great lighting in the bathroom and in the room. The room itself was quite spacious, and there was a good-sized closet as well. There was adequate hot water and excellent water pressure for 4 adults to shower at any hour. Although the hotel was under renovations, there was still a general feeling of good quality and luxury. My family and I felt very safe and 'at home'. Unfortunately, the service and resolution of issues was not up to standards.
I have stayed at many 'InterContinental Hotels Group' hotels (including other Crowne Plaza's and many Holiday Inn's), and have graciously grown to expect a fairly high level of service and quality/luxury. I have also grown to expect that most aspects of a room/overall stay will be in order...and if there is an issue, that it be dealt with swiftly and professionally.
This was NOT the case with this hotel. Surprisingly, none of the staff were very pleasant or professional, nor overly helpful. The issues that I brought to the staff's attention were not resolved, eventhough I was very pleasant and courteous when making light of the issues. These issues were: there was no hotel directory in my room, the phone did not make outgoing calls, the coffee maker was broken, there were no club amenities delivered, there were not enough towels, and the people beside us were fairly loud. All issues were rather surprising, given the quality and luxury of other Crowne Plaza hotels that I've stayed at in other cities.
I absolutely did NOT feel as if I received good value for the money I paid. I paid for an executive room....expecting 46th floor, view of Broadway, upgraded amenities, a club lounge, etc. I was placed in a regular room, 5 floors below and it had a few issues (mentioned above).
Conveniently for the staff and management, there were no comment cards available upon request, and there was nobody available to hear feedback.
Up until this stay, I have always been extremely impressed with IHG hotels...especially Crowne Plaza's. I always proudly give very positive feedback and praise where it is deserved. Based on this stay, I will not be recommending this hotel to anyone I know. I would, however, highly recommend the Holiday Inn Fifth Avenue (which is very close by). I might give this hotel a second chance in the future, but not anytime soon.
I genuinely hate to say that my family and I were quite displeased with our stay overall, and with the service we received. :(
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.