I stayed here for two nights on business, booking this hotel based on previous reviews. And guess what? The reviews are correct! This place doesn't over-promise - it's not a 5* luxury hotel, but everything is clean, calm and well cared-for. My room was a good size (for Manhattan standards). It looked newly fitted-out. Bathroom was clean and new - shower had lots of power. And it was quiet at night. Breakfast was easy going and friendly. I would definitely stay here again - the $299 rate I paid was good value from a business travel perspective.

Great rate compared to other hotels in area. Rooms are very clean and new. Tiny but cozy with flat screen tv -nice size bathroom and very nice staff. Location is great---near Penn station-various subways lines in either direction on street ( 28th).
Neutrogena products-lots of hot water and good pressure. Comfy beds.

This is my new favorite for the area - the place is newly renovated so it's clean. The room has a refrigerator, microwave, flat-screen hdtv with a HD cable tv with channel guide. Free bottled water in the room, and free high-speed internet (wired and wi-fi). Printer access in the lobby. Fresh baked cookies in the evening!

My husband & I stayed here because we were seeing a concert at MSG. It is a very short walk to the Garden and Penn Station. The rooms are not large but no too tiny either. From the window in our room, we got a PERFECT view of the Empire State Building. (That was pretty cool!) The TV is a flat screeen HDTV with loads of channels. Other posters had only one complaint about the slow elevators...we must have got lucky because at no time did we have to wait long at all..(although we were there on a weekday...)

I am glad we decided to stay here!