I have nothing but praise for the Roxbury Motel. I am a germaphobe and it was impeccably clean. The service at the office is great, and everyone at the motel was super friendly. Coffee was awesome too! HOWEVER, be prepared to drive around if you want to do anything. There is NOTHING to Roxbury. It's like two blocks long total. One of those blocks was an old folks' home, a school and some private residences, and the other block was auto parts/thrift shops and a couple of restaurants with the rest of the buildings in foreclosure. We went in three restaurants in Roxbury, and I think they were the only three. Two were for sale and the third was a typical dive bar (T Bar - it was the only thing open on Wednesday night before Memorial Day).
The East Branch Grill was decent but they don't make milkshakes before Mem Day. They have milk. They have ice cream. Something magical must happen that they can't be safely combined pre-Mem Day though. That sticks in my mind as it was about the 50th thing not open/available pre-Mem Day, and at that point my husband asked what I thought. I said I thought Roxbury was the most depressing place I'd ever been. We packed that night and left the next morning, a day before we were scheduled to leave, so we could salvage what was left of our time off together.
The Public Lounge (walking dist from the motel) is fantastic and also from what I recall had a for sale sign inside. Too bad, I hope it thrives because it was really great food and drinks, and the service was every bit as outstanding as at the motel.
There *were* things to do, but I commute 140 miles a day and most things were 30 - 60 mins by car. The last thing I want to do on a vaca is drive an hour to Woodstock or 30 mins to Peekamoose, which by the way was closed until Memorial Day for repairs. Also, scratch the driving range at Shep Hills - not open until - wait for it - Mem Day!!!!
If you are willing to spend a good amount of time driving around to different things/places, this motel is worth a visit. If you want to get somewhere, settle in and have lots of things to do at your fingertips and neat little restaurants and shops, keep driving. We couldn't get out of Roxbury fast enough, which is truly a shame and again had nothing to do with the motel. I wish someone had given me this info before we booked - it would have deterred me from blowing 3 precious vaca days in what can only be described as Depression Era America.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
Would I recommend this hotel to my best friend?
probably not
I recommend this hotel for:
A romantic getaway, People with disabilities, Families with young children, Families with teenagers, Tourists
I do not recommend this hotel for:
Young singles, Girlfriend getaway, Older travelers, Great pool scene, Pet owners
I selected this hotel as a top choice for:
Outdoor / Adventure, Great food / Wine, Shopping, Other
Management Response
Leslie Black, Owner
(Management representative)
May 24, 2008
We would like to thank these guests for their nice comments about our hotel. Because each and every one of our guests' stay is extremely important to us, it pains us a great deal to hear that their experience with the village of Roxbury was not what they expected.
We remember this couple. We saw them walking around the village and it was clear that they were unhappy. They were here midweek in early May (one of the slowest times of the year) and they seemed very upset that the weather was cool and rainy and uncooperative. It kept them from enjoying the many outdoor activities (like hiking, mountain biking, horseback riding, kayaking and canoeing, fishing, and more) that are either right outside the door or less than 15 minutes away from The Roxbury.
If you are looking for Las Vegas or Disneyworld or a shopping mall, then you should probably not come to Roxbury, or any of the villages in the Catskills for that matter. However, to compare the village to depression-era America or post-communist Republic of Georgia is not only a very cruel thing to say, but completely inaccurate.
The sense of place that a centuries-old village like Roxbury offers may not be for everyone, but it has garnered us many return visitors who greatly appreciate its cultural, historical and recreational resources. The whole village is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and was honored by the White House in 2007.
In addition, it is true that you cannot walk outside your hotel door to a large variety of restaurants, but the description of having to drive 30-60 minutes for a good restaurant is also inaccurate. One has only to read some of the other reviews about our area to see that it is possible to come to The Roxbury (even during the middle of the week during off season) and not only enjoy the hotel itself, but also the beauty and the activities that lie within and surround the village.
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.