Growing up Italian on Mom's food, we weren't sure we'd ever find an Italian place we'd like when we moved to Indy. We've tried them all...The chains, the family-owned restaurants. Every time one opened, we'd be there, but we always come back to Amalfi's. Amalfi's is consistently excellent and, by far, the most authentic Italian food in Indy. Even Mom... more

Haven't been in a while, but this is a nice, out-of-the-way, not mainstream place. more

Love this place. Specials tend to be redundant. more

My wife and I live in Indy and this is by far our favorite restaurant! Run by Chef Mario and his wife with kitchen help from Mario's first-generation Italian mother, we're always pleased with both the food and the service. We go back over and over, and our favorite waiter remembers our name from one visit to the next. The... more

A friend of Italian heritage took us to Amalfi's, saying it was the best Italian in Indianapolis. It's located in a strip shopping center at a fairly busy intersection, which is quite an odd location, but the restaurant itself is small and quite nice. The wait staff was friendly and not overly stuffy, and the dinner was quite good. Two... more