We thought this was good enough that we ate there for 2 dinners on our August 2008 trip to the Keys. We got stuffed dolphin, chardonnay dolphin, teriyaki dolphin, grilled dolphin sandwich and chicken fettuccini. All were wonderful. This place had the best key lime pie that we tried on our trip!! Great location to watch the sunset. They make... more

First, we waited for 30 minutes before anyone asked if we wanted a drink. We actually tried to flag down 3 different servers waiting tables nearby and they ignored us. Then we had to ask the hostess if she could tell the waitstaff we were ready. Finally, someone came over to help us. My fish had tons of bones in... more

my wife and i had been in the keys all week and were travelling back to miami to fly home to nc. we stopped here for lunch and it was very very good. i had fried oysters and fried scallops. they were some of the best i've eaten. my wife had fried shrimp, it too was excellant. we had conch... more

To be honest, I did not realize this restaurant was a chain until I came back and started reading the reviews on this website. I went here because I was looking for a great place to eat and heard this place was wonderful. We went looking for it since we were in Key Largo and had to drive a while... more

We really enjoyed Islamorada Fish Co. It's the only place we went to twice. We had grilled scallops, grouper, and snapper between us and it was super. The service both times was friendly, helpful, and attentive. Some places try too hard, but IFC just seemed to work hard and get it right. Location and view is fabulous. more

When a chain takes over you get chain quality food. Makes me sad to remember how good it used to be. You can't destroy the beautiful gulf view and sunset - but the food adds nothing to the experience. Go for the view - eat food elsewhere. The lack of wait these days tells you people are catching on. more

The setting is terrific, overlooking the bay area in a large covered dining area; the food is OK. Nothing bad, just average. When my order arrived my fish was fried instead of broiled or grilled as I had ordered. She suggested it was my fault, but replaced the order after I insisted. After that, things went smoothly. The prices are... more

FIrst, the location was good. Nice view, outdoor dining a plus. They get points for that. The location is pretty spectacular. Points off for rude service. While waiting for a table, we went to the bar, and the bartender was exceedingly rude. We greeted him, and he said, "I said, JUST A MINUTE...." Hmm, since we had just that minute... more

Dinner was a dissapointment. When the Islamorada Fish Company was a small establishment many years ago, the fish/ seafood was outstanding. Since they have expanded the business and are quite well known, I believe that over the years they have been resting on their laurels. The quality has suffered and the size of the food portions (in our case we... more