The only in my book homemade pasta on the island - not taking away from the marvelous hospitality. more

Missed the opportunity to dine at Antonias last year (went to the Opera, ughhh!) but did visit this year. Wow, had a very romantic dinner, Chicken Marsala to die for, amazing fettuccini...just a very, unrushed, delicious dinner. The very best in Italian in Key West. more

A real treat. Service was great, John was attentive but not too much and our dinner was terrific. Can't think of anything they could have done better. We ordered from the daily special menu as well as the regular menu and we weren't dissapointed. We will be back! more

We went to Key West at the end of March for 10 days and ate at a different restaurant every day so we could enjoy the variety of the island. We didn't find Antonia's until our second to the last night there but it was soo delicious and fabulous we went and ate there again on our last day. The... more

we try to dine here when ever we get to town. The lovely dining room is always cool and elegant and we have always been treated well by all of the servers. The specials always sound so tempting, but the homemade pasta always wins me over and the profiteroles are out of this world! more

We found this place just wandering around. The host was busy and took a while to come get us, but after that the service was perfect. Our waiter was a very skilled middle-aged gentleman who was friendly, witty, and really made our night. I wish I remembered his name. My friend and I are 30, but she especially looks very... more

I lived in Key West for over 15 years and you hav to understand what you get for your $$ in the Keyes is often, not much. ANTONIA'S is just an Awesome place. It is somwhat small, but it is located right on Duval Street where space is a premium..you sit at tables rather close to other tables and it's... more

We had dinner there Dec 26. We had antipasto followed by very tender and nicely sauced gnocchi, excellent linguini con vongole, and first-rate zuppa di pesce. Service was very attentive. The only knock on Antonia's is that the lighting is a bit dim. more

My friends celebrated Christmas Eve at this restaurant. The waitress was uptight, unfriendly and very rude. The food wasn't bad but because of her attitude - we weren't able to enjoy the meal (expensive). Try this place but only if you are looking for miserable service and "no snooty" servers more