We arrived and were told we had no reservation, even though we had a confirmation number which they said was not valid! After checking some more they said we had a reservation for two nights earlier and were marked as a no show - we told them that we had made the reservation for this night, but they insisted we... more

Formally known as All American Inn is now a Rodeway Inn and the renovations really show. We were with a group of motorcyclist consisting of about 20 people and were greeted with smiles and friendliness even though all 20 people flocked at the check in desk all at one time...the staff was very helpful to get us all checked in... more

We were rather disappointed with our stay during the Sturgis motorcycle rally. Our first clue that all might not be well was when searching for a room in Spearfish 8 months earlier only this motel had rooms available. The rooms carpet (light pink) was dirty and spotted, the shower had very little pressure, and there was no mini-fridge, small coffee... more

Two Rapid City soccer teams called this hotel for reservations and confirmed that they had an indoor pool and continental breakfast. The morning before evening arrival, we called to confirm reservations and the pool noting that our kids were really excited to be in the pool after playing soccer. When we arrived, the pool room was closed, dark, a tarp... more

Stayed at this hotel on 10-13-06 while traveling through the Black Hills. Had read previous reviews and decided to give it a try. The teenage girl at the front desk wasn't overly friendly yet she wasn't rude either. More than likely she would've rather been somewhere else on a Friday night. Regardless, our room was clean and comfy and that... more

We were passing through Spearfish for one night on route to Wyoming. After visiting a few of the other hotels in the area which were either over-priced or we were put off by unhelpful reception staff we opted for this All American Inn. The receptionist was very welcoming as was the overall appearance of this establishment. It is bright and... more

The All American Inn in spearfish, SD is a wonderful and warm environment. I noticed that the front desk people always greeted me with a big warm smile. They were curtious and helpful. The prices for a room were competitive to the other hotels. The AAI is set in a great location not far from coffee shops, diners, eateries, and... more