Some people are questioning whether or not this is the nicest place to stay in Eureka and it absolutely is! For the price, it's a huge room, nothing fancy, but it's clean and close to everything. Most people are just passing through Eureka, so I'm not sure what more you need! It was updated and the bathroom was clean and... more

The Bayview was great - clean and very spacious. My husband and I were traveling w/ our 1 year old and my parents so we decided to go with the 2 room suite, which was perfect (two bathrooms even!) esp. for the price. The view is pretty industrial, but the sunset was great. And the location couldn't have been better... more

I booked a room at the Bayview after reading reviews that called it the best place to stay in Eureka. After spending two nights there, my husband and I would have to agree (thus the 5-star rating). While they're not fancy, the rooms are huge, comfortable, and very clean. We stayed in room 210, which is a king room, second... more

The title is not meant to be an insult. The Bayview was adequate: clean, comfy, had a TV and all of the standard amenities you would get at a La Quinta (except for the breakfast!) but I just can’t believe it is the #1 rated hotel in Eureka. The view is technically of the bay, I suppose, but what you... more

We stayed at the Bayview Motel in Eureka, CA for 3 nights in late July, 2008. I have booked rooms "sight unseen" before with only an internet picture to go by and have always regretted it. This experience was just the opposite. I reserved the jacuzzi room with a fireplace. The room was more spacious than any hotel room I've... more

Stayed at the Bayview July 13th on the way to Yachats coming from Napa. Picked the Bayview based on the reviews read here, and was not disappointed! Remember though, this is just a standard motel, nothing fancy. First the good: The room was very clean, spacious, and laid out nicely. We brought our pooch on this trip and the room... more

We found the older owners of this hotel to be charming. Check-in was a breeze, and the room was big. The wi-fi signal was not the strongest, but eventually we got it to work. The "view" isn't anything to write home about, b/c you can see the pulp mill belching smoke. But compared to the prices at other chain motels... more

My wife and I were planning to visit northern California lighthouses and read the reviews of Bay View Motel with great interest. I promptly call the motel directly over a month in advance and made a reservation and gave our contact phone number. The owner quoted me $92 a night and we reserved with my American Express Card. Tired and... more

We had a nice big king room which was very clean. The decor was new but was a little old fashioned for my taste (my husband says I'm picky!) We had a large bathroom with a good shower. Having read the reviews before we went I was pleasantly surprised that the noise from the road was not as bad as... more